Labor Law Doctrinal MCQs
Based on the 2008-2009 Bar Examinations. Select an answer for each question and click submit.
1. A deed of release, waiver, or quitclaim is generally considered invalid under which of the following circumstances?
Authority:
2. Does the workers’ right to participate in policy and decision-making, under the Constitution, include automatic membership in the corporation’s Board of Directors?
Authority:
3. Which of the following disputes falls under the traditional jurisdiction of a Voluntary Arbitrator?
Authority:
4. Can a dispute falling under the exclusive jurisdiction of a Labor Arbiter be submitted to voluntary arbitration?
Authority:
5. Savoy Department Store (SDS) hires salesladies on five-month contracts to avoid regularization. They perform activities necessary to SDS’s business. What is their correct employment status?
Authority:
6. Can the Secretary of Labor assume jurisdiction over a hunger strike at a department store that is not engaged in a business of national interest?
Authority:
7. A DOLE Regional Director, during a routine inspection, discovers that a company is violating security of tenure provisions. Can the Regional Director issue a compliance order to regularize the employees?
Authority:
8. Pedro has been an “extra waiter” for a hotel for over 10 years, called to work on weekends, holidays, and during big events. What is his employment status?
Authority:
9. A service agreement stipulates that there is “no employer-employee relationship” between the principal (PizCorp) and the contractor’s employees (RSC members). Is this stipulation binding on labor officials?
Authority:
10. PizCorp retains the power to impose disciplinary sanctions, including dismissal, on the delivery riders supplied by RSC. Who is considered the employer of the riders?
Authority:
11. A contractor (RSC) has a paid-up capitalization of P1,000,000.00 and supplies workers whose performance is controlled by the principal (PizCorp). What is the status of RSC?
Authority:
12. A union defies a return-to-work order from the Secretary of Labor and continues a protest rally. What is the nature of this action?
Authority:
13. What is the consequence for union officers who knowingly participate in a strike that violates an assumption of jurisdiction order (AJO)?
Authority:
14. An employee requests his employer to stop deducting SSS monthly contributions, stating he is waiving his social security coverage. Should the employer grant this request?
Authority:
15. An employee is killed while waiting for public transport at her usual spot on her way to work. Is her death compensable under the Employees’ Compensation Program?
Authority:
16. When a principal is found to be the employer in a labor-only contracting arrangement, who has the primary obligation to report the workers for SSS membership and remit premiums?
Authority:
17. An airline terminates a flight steward for consistently failing to meet its weight requirement policy, which is justified for safety reasons. The steward argues it is a medical issue. Is the dismissal valid?
Authority:
18. Waitresses in a cocktail lounge do not receive a direct salary but share in service charges and receive tips. When their share falls below minimum wage, they are terminated for demanding an increase. Is the dismissal lawful?
Authority:
19. An employee refuses to render overtime work due to a compelling personal reason (sending off his wife overseas). The company dismisses him for insubordination. Is the dismissal valid?
Authority:
20. During a strike by the rank-and-file union, the supervisors are unable to work. Is the company liable for the supervisors’ salaries for the duration of the strike?
Authority:
21. A labor federation wins a certification election. Subsequently, the local union it represents dissolves. Can the federation still demand to bargain collectively on behalf of the employees?
Authority:
22. Is an employment contract prohibiting employment in a competing company for one year after separation generally considered valid?
Authority:
23. What is the status of confidential employees with respect to the right to unionize for collective bargaining?
Authority:
24. Under what circumstance does a “runaway shop” constitute an unfair labor practice (ULP)?
Authority:
25. What is the core principle of the “substitutionary doctrine” in labor relations?
Authority:
26. Does the P5,000.00 jurisdictional limit for individual money claims apply to the visitorial and enforcement powers of the DOLE Regional Director under Article 128?
Authority:
27. In a case involving an alleged theft by an employee, the NLRC reversed the Labor Arbiter’s ruling in favor of the employee, stating that Article 4 of the Labor Code (construction in favor of labor) does not apply to the application of the Rules on Evidence. Is the NLRC correct?
Authority:
28. An OFW’s deployment was cancelled after his contract was approved by the POEA. What is the extent of the recruitment agencies’ liability for damages?
Authority:
29. A carpenter is hired as a “project employee” to build a house, but the contract does not specify a completion date. Is the completion of the house a valid cause for termination?
Authority:
30. An employee was absent for 8 months because he was incarcerated but later acquitted. He was dismissed for AWOL. Is he entitled to reinstatement and backwages?
Authority:
31. A bus conductor is dismissed for fraud after intentionally not issuing a ticket to a passenger. He argues he cannot be dismissed for breach of trust because he is not a confidential employee. Is he correct?
Authority:
32. An employer asks his domestic helper (kasambahay) to give him a private massage, citing the duty to minister to his “personal comfort and convenience.” Is the helper’s refusal tenable?
Authority:
33. What is the key distinction between a “househelper” (kasambahay) and a “homeworker”?
Authority:
34. A union president is dismissed for spending 95% of his work hours on union activities. The union immediately goes on strike. Management claims the strike is illegal for failure to observe the cooling-off period. Is management correct?
Authority:
35. A final decision by a Labor Arbiter finding management guilty of Unfair Labor Practice (ULP) is used as the basis for a criminal case against the manager. Is this finding sufficient to secure a criminal conviction?
Authority:
36. An employer is ordered to reinstate an employee by the Labor Arbiter. Can the employer be compelled to reinstate pending appeal, even after posting an appeal bond?
Authority:
37. If an employer wishes to comply with a reinstatement order but actual reinstatement is not feasible, what is a legally recognized alternative?
Authority:
38. Can a labor union legally invoke “wage distortion” as a ground to go on strike?
Authority:
39. What is the proper procedural remedy for workers in an unorganized establishment who seek to correct a wage distortion?
Authority:
40. Can a member of a cooperative be considered an employee of that cooperative for purposes of compulsory SSS coverage?
Authority:
41. Are seafarers who have worked for 20 years on the same vessel considered regular employees?
Authority:
42. Is the employment of children below 15 years of age absolutely prohibited?
Authority:
43. Do government employees have the right to engage in concerted mass actions like strikes?
Authority:
44. Is a waiver of the right to claim overtime pay legally valid?
Authority:
45. Is a written authorization from a non-union member required before an employer can deduct agency fees?
Authority:
46. A managing partner of a firm is expelled and files an illegal dismissal case with the NLRC. Does the Labor Arbiter have jurisdiction?
Authority:
47. A job contractor (MMSI) has a paid-up capital of P2M, its only client is Jolli-Mac, and a Jolli-Mac director is a major owner of MMSI. Is the service agreement valid?
Authority:
48. In a certification election with 400 eligible voters, 396 valid votes were cast. Union A got 70, Union B got 71, Union C got 42, Union D got 33, and “No Union” got 180. Can Union B be certified as the winner?
Authority:
49. In the same election scenario (A-70, B-71, C-42, D-33, No Union-180), what is the proper course of action for the election officer?
Authority:
50. When is the “freedom period” for filing a petition for certification election?
Authority:
51. After a CBA expires and negotiations are ongoing, can management unilaterally withdraw the fringe benefits contained in the expired CBA?
Authority:
52. An employee is dismissed for a just cause (serious misconduct) but was not afforded procedural due process. What is he entitled to?
Authority:
53. Which of the following is a recognized ground for awarding separation pay in lieu of reinstatement to an illegally dismissed employee?
Authority:
54. How does a union security clause in a CBA impact an employee’s right to security of tenure?
Authority:
55. Which of the following constitutional policies is NOT explicitly mentioned in Article 3 of the Labor Code (Declaration of Basic Policy)?
Authority:
56. A security guard is on “floating status” for six months because no client will accept him. Has he been constructively dismissed?
Authority:
57. Can a dispute falling within the jurisdiction of a voluntary arbitrator be submitted to compulsory arbitration by the Secretary of Labor?
Authority:
58. Under R.A. 11360, how are service charges collected by establishments like restaurants and hotels to be distributed?
Authority:
59. Did Atty. Renan commit sexual harassment when he invited a newly-hired employee, Miss Maganda, for dinner and dancing while hinting at his influence over promotions?
Authority:
60. Who is compulsorily covered by the Government Service Insurance Act (GSIS)?
Authority:
61. What is the primary legal consequence for a union that fails to comply with the mandatory strike-vote requirement before staging a strike?
Authority:
62. A security agency (JSA) cannot provide an assignment to a guard (Alexander) for six months. The Labor Arbiter orders immediate reinstatement. Is a separate motion for a writ of execution necessary to enforce this order?
Authority:
63. What defines a “wage distortion”?
Authority:
64. In an organized establishment, what is the first step in the procedural remedy for correcting a wage distortion?
Authority:
65. Which of the following government employees is excluded from compulsory GSIS coverage?
Authority:
66. A proposed law seeks to abolish the security of tenure clause in the Labor Code. From a constitutional standpoint, how should a judge rule on its validity?
Authority:
67. If a law allows contractualization of services directly related to an employer’s business operations, how does this conflict with established jurisprudence?
Authority:
68. In a certification election, can the management of a company legally ask for the proceedings to be terminated because a plurality of voters chose “No Union”?
Authority:
69. If a CBA expires on December 31, 2007, and negotiations for a new one are ongoing, can another union file a petition for certification election on April 3, 2008?
Authority:
70. An employee is dismissed for a valid, just cause. However, the employer failed to provide a notice of dismissal. What is the legal status of the termination?
Authority:
71. Which of the following is NOT a recognized valid reinstatement bar where separation pay may be awarded instead?
Authority:
72. What are the “twin requirements” of statutory due process in employee dismissal?
Authority:
73. The right of workers to participate in policy-making does NOT cover which of the following?
Authority:
74. Under what condition can a dispute within the jurisdiction of a Voluntary Arbitrator be taken over by a compulsory arbitration body?
Authority:
75. A company implements a policy of hiring employees for fixed five-month terms to perform tasks essential to its main business. This practice is a violation of which employee right?
Authority:
76. What is the legal basis for concluding that PizCorp is the employer of the RSC members, despite an agreement to the contrary?
Authority:
77. A contractor is deemed to be engaged in “labor-only” contracting if it lacks substantial capital AND what other condition is met?
Authority:
78. An Assumption of Jurisdiction Order (AJO) by the Secretary of Labor has what immediate legal effect on a planned or ongoing strike?
Authority:
79. Why is an employee’s waiver of SSS coverage considered void?
Authority:
80. The “going-to-and-from-work” rule in employees’ compensation is negated by which of the following?
Authority:
81. An airline’s weight requirement policy for flight attendants, justified by passenger safety, is considered what kind of right for the employer?
Authority:
82. An employee’s failure to meet a reasonable company standard, despite being given ample time and assistance, can constitute which just cause for dismissal?
Authority:
83. Insubordination as a just cause for dismissal requires a willful violation of a reasonable directive AND what other element?
Authority:
84. What legal principle justifies the non-payment of salaries to non-striking employees (e.g., supervisors) who are unable to work due to a strike by other employees (e.g., rank-and-file)?
Authority:
85. A labor federation charters a local union. Who holds the right to be the sole and exclusive bargaining representative after a successful certification election?
Authority:
86. A non-compete clause is deemed void if its specific effect is which of the following?
Authority:
87. Why are confidential employees disqualified from unionizing for collective bargaining purposes?
Authority:
88. The “substitutionary doctrine” primarily serves to promote what objective in labor relations?
Authority:
89. The DOLE Regional Director’s power under Article 128 of the Labor Code is for “rectification cases,” while the power under Article 129 is for what type of cases?
Authority:
90. The liberal interpretation rule in Article 4 of the Labor Code applies to doubts arising from the Labor Code, its implementing rules, labor contracts, and what else?
Authority:
91. An OFW’s contract is perfected upon its approval by the POEA, but when is the employer-employee relationship deemed to have been established?
Authority:
92. What is the due process requirement for an employer when terminating a project employee upon the completion of the project?
Authority:
93. An employee was dismissed for an apparent abandonment of work. It was later discovered the absence was due to a valid reason (wrongful detention). What is the proper remedy?
Authority:
94. Breach of trust as a ground for dismissal applies to managerial employees and which other category of employees?
Authority:
95. The provisions of the Labor Code on domestic helpers have been largely supplanted by what law?
Authority:
96. A homeworker is distinguished from a kasambahay in that a homeworker performs what activity?
Authority:
97. A finding of ULP by a Labor Arbiter is a prerequisite for filing a criminal action. What is the effect of this finding on the criminal case?
Authority:
98. An employer ordered to reinstate an employee pending appeal has three options: actual reinstatement to the former position, reinstatement to an equivalent position, or what else?
Authority:
99. Which of the following is considered a strikable issue under the Labor Code?
Authority:
100. For a cooperative member to be considered an employee for SSS coverage purposes, what is the most critical factor?
Authority:
101. What is the legal status of seafarers’ employment, according to jurisprudence?
Authority:
102. Under what specific condition is the employment of a child below 15 years old permissible under the Labor Code?
Authority:
103. While government employees have the right to organize, what specific concerted activity is withheld from them by law?
Authority:
104. Why is a waiver of a statutory benefit like overtime pay considered contrary to law?
Authority:
105. The legal basis for collecting agency fees from non-union members who benefit from a CBA is that it is a(n):
Authority:
106. A dispute involving the expulsion of a managing partner from a firm is considered what type of controversy?
Authority:
107. If workers supplied by a labor-only contractor are not paid their lawful wages, against whom can they file their claims?
Authority:
108. To win a certification election, what must a contending union or “No Union” achieve?
Authority:
109. A run-off election is appropriate when no choice gets a majority vote in a certification election, and what other condition is met?
Authority:
110. The principle of non-diminution of benefits under Article 100 of the Labor Code primarily applies to what kind of benefits?
Authority:
111. What is the impact of a valid union security clause on an employee’s right to refuse to join a union?
Authority:
112. The automatic renewal clause of a CBA applies to which provisions upon the CBA’s expiration?
Authority:
113. Can parties to a labor dispute agree to submit an issue under the Labor Arbiter’s jurisdiction to a Voluntary Arbitrator?
Authority:
114. A Regional Director’s power to issue a compliance order under Article 128 does NOT extend to resolving which issue?
Authority:
115. A contractual stipulation that “no employer-employee relationship exists” is not binding on labor officials because the relationship is ultimately a question of:
Authority:
116. A continuing protest rally that involves a temporary stoppage of work due to a labor dispute is substantially a:
Authority:
117. What is the consequence for ordinary union members who participate in an illegal strike but have not committed any illegal acts?
Authority:
118. In a labor-only contracting arrangement, the legal personality of the labor-only contractor is considered to have what relationship with the principal?
Authority:
119. A petition for certification election filed during the “freedom period” is timely. A petition filed after the CBA has expired but before a new one is signed is considered:
Authority:
120. A dismissal is for a just cause, but the employer violates procedural due process. The employee is not entitled to reinstatement or backwages, but is entitled to what?
Authority:
